In a small pot, add ground black pepper, crushed clove buds (and whole stems), Ceylon cinnamon, nutmeg, whole bay leaf, orange peel, vanilla bean, sugar, and 1/4 cup of red wine.
Turn heat on low, and cook until mixture forms into a syrup.*
Add the remaining red wine into pot and continue heating until it warms to your preferred temperature.
If you don’t mind a bit of ground spice on the bottom of the wine glass, ladle the mulled wine directly into a glass. If you want a cleaner look, run the mulled wine through a fine strainer before serving.
Notes
* Step from Jamie Oliver’s recipe- Try your own spice blend to find the flavor that works best for you. You’ll have a new appreciation for cheap red wine!